Monologues, dialogues, and common priors

The main purpose of this paper is to provide a simple criterion enabling to con- clude that two agents do not share a common prior. The criterion is simple, as it does not require information about the agents’ knowledge and beliefs, but rather only the record of a dialogue between the agents. In each stage of the dialogue, the agents tell each other the probability they ascribe to a fixed event and update their beliefs about the event. To characterize dialogues consistent with a common prior, we first study monologues, which are sequences of probabilities assigned by a single agent to a given event in an exogenous learning process. A dialogue is con- sistent with a common prior if and only if each selection sequence from the two monologues comprising the dialogue is itself a monologue.