A portfolio-based evaluation of affine term structure models

We focus on affine term structure models as tools for active bond portfolio management. Our financial exercise comprises the following steps: 1) forecast the future values of the state variables implied by several multi-factor models; 2) approximate the conditional moments of the state vector to come up with discrete scenarios for the future state variables; 3) compute bond returns for various maturities at future dates from the theoretical asset pricing relations; 4) solve the portfolio problem faced by an investor with a six month horizon who takes into account the possibility to rebalance after one quarter. The sequence of optimal portfolios is evaluated in terms of financial properties. We show that a financial based evaluation of term structure models may yield results conflicting with those obtained from a statistical evaluation.